I was pretty close to buying the Mach-E, it has some nice features that I would like. I was okay with the looks (infinite blue), but the retro tail lights were a bit much for me, more so the price. I never had a stang (I can talk that way now as an ex-Mach-E forum member), mostly Hondas and Subarus before my crusade to try as many EVs as I could last decade.
I kind of liked the Mach-E front look and curves (could care less about a frunk or the pony). The ID.4 looks more like a generic young family or grandparents cuv to me. One of my friends says it looks like something (esp. the white steering wheel) out of a 1980's Wood Allen Sci Fi movie. It's okay to me. I like the VW blue color. It looks like it could have a plastic daisy on the telescoping FM antenna if we still had those (1960s/70s reference).
It's funny the way we all view looks. Was it here, or over at Mach-E, where someone said the Model Y looks like someone with a stocking pulled over their head! I kind of like the look of the Model 3 (another close miss for me), less so the Y, but it was still tempting.
I wonder if car looks and norms will change faster now, like the earlier Apple upgrade analogy. In the 1980s I had a craving for a Mercedes 500SL. Now it looks so dated to me.