I self-debated this for quite some time as well, especially given I've had Quattro for the past decade in three vehicles and several 4WD Jeeps the decade prior. There's no question that in Winter/offroad driving it instills confidence. However ultimately I considered just how often I would be in snow/ice/gravel and in operation significant enough where AWD would truly be beneficial. In my 99% intended use I just couldn't justify a need. For me [add'l] cost as an independent variable, but the weight of an additional electric motor, and its use, was an engineering consideration factor in range.
Also related I drove my daughter's regifted to me FWD Mazda 6 (after I bought her a Mini Countryman AWD) as a 'Winter beater' extensively for two seasons and had no issues whatsoever. Some would argue that FWD is superior to RWD in that respect and there is merit to that viewpoint. But then I cast my memory back to my teen driving when most all vehicles were RWD, and bias ply tires, and somehow I'm still here to relate, so ....

We all need to fairly and as objectively as possible evaluate our actual needs (vs. wants). First world indeed tho'. 🙂
1st world problems

I am in the same boat ... some time to consider, but I am 99% sure I'd stay with Pro S AWD because of AWD